Book Review: The Cuckoo’s Calling by Robert Galbraith, Book One.
When The Cuckoo’s Calling was first published in 2013, it arrived quietly on the literary scene, touted as the debut novel of an unknown author, Robert Galbraith. It wasn’t long before the truth emerged. Galbraith was a pseudonym for none other than J.K. Rowling, the internationally acclaimed author of the Harry Potter series. The revelation cast a new light on the novel and drew a flood of attention to this foray into the crime fiction genre. While comparisons to Rowling’s earlier works were inevitable, The Cuckoo’s Calling established itself as a solid, standalone detective story. With a compelling plot, intricate characters, and a richly textured London setting.
Plot Summary
The story begins with the apparent suicide of supermodel Lula Landry, who falls to her death from her Mayfair apartment balcony. Her death is widely presumed to be a tragic accident, fuelled by the pressures of fame and mental health struggles. However, her brother, John Bristow, is unconvinced and hires private detective Cormoran Strike to investigate further. Strike, a war veteran with a prosthetic leg and a pile of personal and financial troubles, reluctantly takes on the case.
What follows is a traditional whodunit wrapped in a modern urban noir aesthetic. As Strike delves deeper into Lula’s life, he encounters a world of glitzy celebrity culture, cutthroat ambition and murky secrets. The investigation takes him to various corners of London, from upscale neighbourhoods to grimy streets. Introducing a colourful cast of suspects, including Lula’s troubled boyfriend, her jealous friends, and her estranged family members. Alongside Strike is his temporary assistant, Robin Ellacott, whose intelligence and resourcefulness quickly prove indispensable. Together, they uncover a tangled web of lies and motivations, leading to a shocking conclusion that upends the initial assumptions about Lula’s death.
Characterisation
One of the novel’s greatest strengths lies in its characters. Cormoran Strike is a refreshing departure from the archetypal hardboiled detective. Unlike the slick, infallible private eyes of classic noir fiction, Strike is deeply human, grappling with physical and emotional scars. His backstory marked by a tumultuous childhood, a high profile breakup, and his military service, adds depth and vulnerability to his character. Rowling’s nuanced portrayal makes Strike both relatable and admirable, as he navigates his struggles with quiet determination and a wry sense of humour.
Robin Ellacott, the other central figure, is equally well-crafted. Initially hired as a temporary secretary, Robin quickly becomes an essential part of the investigation. Her enthusiasm for detective work contrasts with her practical and efficient demeanour. Creating a dynamic partnership with Strike. The evolving relationship between the two is a highlight of the novel, marked by mutual respect and a subtle undercurrent of tension. Robin’s character brings a fresh perspective to the story, balancing Strike’s gruff pragmatism with her warmth and ingenuity.
The supporting cast is equally memorable. From the enigmatic and tragic Lula Landry to her manipulative brother John Bristow. Each character is given a distinct voice and motivation, and Rowling’s keen observational skills shine through in her portrayal of their quirks and contradictions. The suspects are not merely caricatures. They are complex individuals whose actions and secrets are rooted in believable human behaviour.
Themes
At its core, The Cuckoo’s Calling is more than a murder mystery. It is an exploration of themes like identity, fame, and the pervasive influence of the media. Through Lula Landry’s life and death, Rowling examines the pressures of celebrity culture. Where individuals are scrutinised, commodified, and ultimately dehumanised. The novel also delves into the complexities of family relationships. As seen in the contrasting dynamics between Lula and her adoptive relatives.
The theme of identity is particularly poignant, as many characters grapple with questions of self-perception and societal expectations. Lula’s biracial heritage and her adoption into a wealthy white family add layers of complexity to her character. Highlighting issues of belonging and cultural disconnection. Strike’s struggles with his physical disability and his estranged relationship with his rock-star father further underscore the novel’s exploration of identity.
Setting and Atmosphere
Rowling’s vivid descriptions of London breathe life into the novel’s setting. Transforming the city into a character in its own right. From the bustling streets of Soho to the quiet opulence of Mayfair, the narrative paints a richly detailed portrait of the city’s diverse landscapes. The atmospheric descriptions enhance the mood of the story. Immersing readers in the glamour and grit of modern-day London. The juxtaposition of wealth and poverty, glamour and decay, mirrors the contrasts within the characters and their lives.
Writing Style
Rowling’s prose in The Cuckoo’s Calling is polished and evocative, demonstrating her mastery of storytelling. Her ability to weave intricate details into the narrative without overwhelming the reader is evident throughout the book. The dialogue is sharp and authentic, capturing the nuances of different characters’ speech patterns and personalities. The pacing is deliberate, allowing for a gradual buildup of suspense and a satisfying unraveling of the mystery.
One criticism that has been leveled at the novel is its occasional over-reliance on exposition. While the detailed backstories and meticulous descriptions enrich the narrative, they can sometimes slow the pace, particularly in the early chapters. However, for readers who appreciate character-driven stories and immersive world-building, these elements are more of a feature than a flaw.
Comparisons and Influences
As a crime novel, The Cuckoo’s Calling pays homage to the classic detective fiction tradition, drawing inspiration from authors like Agatha Christie and Raymond Chandler. The structure of the novel, with its closed circle of suspects and carefully planted clues, echoes the golden age of mystery writing. At the same time, Strike’s character shares some similarities with modern literary detectives, such as Michael Connelly’s Harry Bosch or Ian Rankin’s John Rebus, who are defined by their moral complexity and personal struggles.
Despite these influences, Rowling brings her own distinctive voice to the genre. Her ability to craft multifaceted characters and explore social themes adds a layer of depth that elevates the novel beyond a conventional mystery.
Impact and Legacy
Upon its release, The Cuckoo’s Calling received critical acclaim, with reviewers praising its intricate plot, compelling characters, and atmospheric setting. The subsequent revelation of Rowling’s authorship sparked renewed interest in the book, propelling it to bestseller status. While some skeptics questioned whether the novel would have received the same attention without Rowling’s name attached, the quality of the writing speaks for itself.The book’s success led to the launch of the Cormoran Strike series, which now includes several sequels, each building on the foundation laid by The Cuckoo’s Calling. The series has been adapted into a television drama, further cementing its place in contemporary crime.
Conclusion
The Cuckoo’s Calling is a masterfully crafted mystery that combines the best elements of traditional detective fiction with a modern sensibility. With its richly drawn characters, intricate plot, and evocative setting, the novel offers a thoroughly engaging reading experience. While it may not reinvent the genre, it demonstrates Rowling’s versatility as a writer and her ability to tell a compelling story in any context. For fans of crime fiction and character-driven narratives, The Cuckoo’s Calling is a must-read, setting the stage for what promises to be a memorable series.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links on this site may be affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. This helps support Crimes in Bramley and allows us to continue to create content. Thank you for your support!
Richards Osman’s “The Thursday Murder Club” and brand new Crime series “We Solve Murders” reviewed Here.
