Book Review: The Silkworm by Robert Galbraith, Book Two
The Silkworm (2014), the second novel in Robert Galbraith’s (a pseudonym for J.K. Rowling) Cormoran Strike series, takes readers on a gripping journey into the dark and shadowy world of literary London. Building on the foundation laid by The Cuckoo’s Calling, this instalment deepens the character development of its central duo—private detective Cormoran Strike and his assistant Robin Ellacott—while delivering a compelling and intricate mystery. Through a blend of sharp prose, vivid characterisation, and a labyrinthine plot, The Silkworm offers a fascinating exploration of the publishing industry, the complexities of human nature, and the lengths people will go to protect their secrets.
Plot Summary
The novel begins when Strike is hired by Leonora Quine to find her husband, Owen Quine, a once-promising novelist whose career has faltered. Quine has vanished, leaving behind a literary scandal involving his unpublished manuscript, Bombyx Mori (Latin for “silkworm”). This grotesque and allegorical work, laced with venomous caricatures of people in Owen’s life, has enraged those it portrays and offers a treasure trove of potential motives for his disappearance.
Strike’s investigation takes a dark turn when Owen’s body is discovered in a macabre tableau that mirrors a scene from his manuscript. Bound, disemboweled, and covered in acid-drenched entrails, Quine’s murder is both horrifying and bizarre. As Strike delves deeper into the case, he uncovers a tangled web of jealousies, betrayals, and ambition among Quine’s circle of publishers, editors, and literary rivals.
Meanwhile, Robin’s aspirations to become more involved in Strike’s investigations create tension between the two. Robin is eager to prove herself, but Strike is hesitant to expose her to the danger inherent in their work. This subplot adds emotional depth and highlights Robin’s determination and evolving relationship with her boss.
As Strike pieces together clues, he uncovers the identity of the killer in a thrilling climax that underscores the themes of revenge, artistic integrity, and the destructive power of ego.
Themes
The Dark Side of Creativity
At its core, The Silkworm is a meditation on the cost of artistic ambition and the fragility of human relationships. Owen Quine’s brutal murder is a metaphorical reflection of the cutthroat literary world, where betrayal and resentment often simmer beneath the surface. The manuscript, Bombyx Mori, serves as both a symbol of Quine’s narcissism and a catalyst for his demise, illustrating how art can be weaponised.
Masks and Authenticity
The novel explores how people construct public personas while concealing their true selves. Many of the characters wear metaphorical masks, hiding their secrets, desires, and fears. Strike himself, with his stoic demeanor and guarded past, exemplifies this theme. Similarly, the literary world portrayed in the novel is rife with façades, where public acclaim masks private turmoil.
Power Dynamics
Galbraith delves into power struggles within relationships, industries, and society. From the manipulation within Quine’s marriage to the professional rivalries in publishing, power dynamics shape the narrative. Strike and Robin’s evolving partnership also reflects a nuanced negotiation of authority and trust.
Characters
Cormoran Strike
Strike continues to be a compelling protagonist—gruff yet empathetic, sharp-witted yet burdened by his physical and emotional scars. His keen observational skills and tenacity are matched by his moments of vulnerability, making him relatable and human. In The Silkworm, his commitment to justice, even when faced with personal and professional challenges, cements his role as a modern literary detective in the vein of classic figures like Sherlock Holmes or Hercule Poirot.
Robin Ellacott
Robin’s character arc is one of the highlights of the novel. Her growing confidence and determination to be more than an assistant add layers to her personality. Her frustration with Strike’s overprotectiveness and her struggle to balance her personal aspirations with her fiancé’s expectations make her journey relatable and engaging.
Owen Quine
Though deceased for much of the novel, Owen Quine is a larger-than-life presence. His narcissism, desperation for recognition, and alienation from his peers and family make him both pitiable and detestable. Quine’s complex personality ensures that his death feels impactful, driving the mystery forward.
Supporting Cast
The array of suspects and secondary characters—from Quine’s wife Leonora to the venomous literary agent Elizabeth Tassel—are vividly drawn, each with their own motivations and secrets. Galbraith excels at creating a tapestry of flawed and fascinating personalities, each of whom could conceivably be the murderer.
Strengths
Richly Drawn Setting
The novel’s depiction of London, especially its literary underbelly, is atmospheric and immersive. Galbraith brings to life everything from dusty bookshops to exclusive publishing houses, creating a vivid backdrop for the mystery.
Complex Plotting
The intricacy of the mystery is one of the book’s greatest strengths. Galbraith expertly weaves red herrings and misdirections, keeping readers guessing until the final reveal. The parallels between Quine’s murder and his manuscript add an extra layer of intrigue.
Dynamic Protagonists
The chemistry between Strike and Robin is a standout feature. Their interactions are a blend of wit, warmth, and tension, and their evolving partnership is as engaging as the central mystery.
Social Commentary
Beyond its narrative, The Silkworm offers incisive commentary on the publishing industry and the darker aspects of fame and success. It’s a pointed critique of how egos and insecurities can poison relationships and creativity.
Weaknesses
Pacing
While the novel’s detailed descriptions and subplots enrich the story, they occasionally slow the pace. Some readers might find the buildup to the murder’s resolution a bit prolonged.
Graphic Content
The grotesque details of Quine’s murder and the explicit nature of his manuscript may be off-putting to some readers. While these elements serve the story, they can feel excessively lurid at times.
Limited Development of Secondary Characters
Although many supporting characters are intriguing, a few feel underdeveloped or serve primarily as plot devices. Expanding their backstories could have added depth to the narrative.
Conclusion
The Silkworm is a masterful addition to the Cormoran Strike series, offering a blend of classic detective storytelling with modern sensibilities. Galbraith’s ability to craft complex characters, atmospheric settings, and intricate mysteries makes the novel a standout in the crime fiction genre. While its pacing and graphic elements may not appeal to everyone, its strengths far outweigh its weaknesses.For fans of literary thrillers and character-driven mysteries, The Silkworm is a must-read. It solidifies Robert Galbraith’s place as a contemporary master of the genre and leaves readers eager for the next installment in Strike and Robin’s adventures.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links on this site may be affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. This helps support Crimes in Bramley and allows us to continue to create content. Thank you for your support!
Richards Osman’s “The Thursday Murder Club” and brand new Crime series “We Solve Murders” reviewed Here.
