Book Review: The Ink Black Heart by Robert Galbraith, Book Six
The Ink Black Heart, the sixth instalment in Robert Galbraith’s (J.K. Rowling’s pseudonym) acclaimed Cormoran Strike series, is a sprawling mystery that intricately weaves modern-day dilemmas with timeless investigative techniques. Published in August 2022, the novel immerses readers in a labyrinthine world of online fandoms, cyberbullying, and the blurred line between virtual and real-life identities. The book is a bold, intricate, and, at times, polarizing addition to the series, offering both rewards and challenges to its readers.
Plot Summary
At the heart of the story lies Edie Ledwell, a co-creator of a cult favourite animated series, The Ink Black Heart. Edie approaches Cormoran Strike and Robin Ellacott, the private detectives at the helm of the story, to help uncover the identity of a vicious online troll who has been targeting her and her creative partner, Josh Blay. Their creation, a quirky, dark animation about a heart-shaped character navigating a macabre underworld, has gained a massive online following. However, its popularity has also attracted toxic fans, factionalised debates, and relentless harassment.
Tragically, before Strike and Robin decide whether to take Edie’s case, she is murdered in a north London cemetery, the same location central to the series’ lore. Her death, coupled with Josh’s near-fatal injuries in the same attack, catapults Strike and Robin into an investigation filled with twists, red herrings, and complex personalities.
What follows is a tale that delves into the murky depths of internet culture, from the anonymity and power it affords to its potential for harm. The detectives navigate a virtual world rife with cryptic usernames, secret chatrooms, and coded threats, while also contending with their own personal and professional struggles.
Themes and Relevance
One of the novel’s strongest points is its deep dive into the darker side of online spaces. Galbraith examines how fandoms, while capable of fostering creativity and community, can devolve into arenas of toxicity, tribalism, and unchecked cruelty. The anonymity of the internet is a recurring motif, highlighting both the empowerment and peril it brings. For readers familiar with the complexities of social media culture, the narrative resonates as a sharp critique of how platforms amplify division and harassment.
The book also explores themes of obsession, identity, and the desire for control. Edie’s murder and the ensuing investigation expose how creators can become ensnared by their audiences and how fandoms can take on lives of their own, often diverging from the original creator’s vision.At the same time, The Ink Black Heart retains the personal focus that has defined the Strike series. Robin’s ongoing struggle to balance her professional ambitions with her emotional well-being is particularly poignant. Her evolving dynamic with Strike a blend of deep camaraderie, unspoken tension, and mutual respect remains a cornerstone of the series.
Characterisation
Cormoran Strike and Robin Ellacott continue to grow as characters, their arcs enriched by the novel’s events. Strike, the gruff but astute detective, remains a compelling lead, though his personal flaws his stubbornness, workaholism, and strained relationships are brought into sharper relief. His physical struggles, stemming from his prosthetic leg and the toll of his demanding profession, add a layer of vulnerability to his character.
Robin, meanwhile, emerges as an increasingly independent and formidable investigator. Her tenacity, intelligence, and empathy shine through, especially as she grapples with misogyny and manipulation in both the physical and digital worlds. The book also delves deeper into Robin’s internal life, including her lingering feelings about her divorce and her growing, if unacknowledged, attraction to Strike.
The supporting cast, ranging from online trolls to eccentric fans, is equally well-drawn. Galbraith excels at crafting believable, multidimensional characters, even when they occupy morally ambiguous spaces. The suspects and witnesses, each with their own quirks and secrets, keep the reader guessing until the very end.
Structure and Writing Style
At over 1,000 pages, The Ink Black Heart is a formidable read. The novel’s length has sparked divided opinions among fans and critics. While some appreciate the detailed exploration of the case and its subplots, others feel that the book’s pacing suffers as a result. There are moments when the narrative feels weighed down by excessive detail, especially in its depiction of online interactions.
A significant portion of the book unfolds through digital dialogues chatroom exchanges, tweets, and private messages. This unconventional narrative technique adds authenticity and immerses readers in the online world central to the story. However, it can also be overwhelming, as the sheer volume of text and fragmented style require close attention to keep track of characters and events.
Galbraith’s prose is characteristically sharp and evocative, capturing both the grim realities of the investigation and the subtle emotional currents between Strike and Robin. The dialogue, particularly in the online exchanges, rings true, reflecting the rhythms and peculiarities of internet culture.
Criticism and Controversy
The Ink Black Heart has not been without its share of controversy. Some readers have drawn parallels between Edie Ledwell’s experiences and J.K. Rowling’s own, particularly her public clashes with critics and online harassment. This perceived meta-commentary has divided opinions, with some praising the book’s candor and others criticising it as self-indulgent.
Additionally, the novel’s depiction of sensitive topics, including cyberbullying and extremist online behaviour, has sparked debate. While the book’s commitment to exploring these issues is commendable, some may find its portrayal of internet culture to be overly cynical or reductive.
Strengths
Despite its polarizing elements, The Ink Black Heart has much to commend. The central mystery is engaging, with numerous twists and a satisfying resolution. The interplay between Strike and Robin remains a highlight, their partnership evolving in ways that feel authentic and earned. The book’s exploration of online culture is timely and thought-provoking, shedding light on issues that resonate in today’s digital age.
Galbraith’s attention to detail and skilful plotting ensure that even the most patient readers are rewarded. The novel’s conclusion ties together its many threads while leaving enough ambiguity to keep fans eager for the next instalment.
Weaknesses
The book’s length and density may deter some readers, particularly those new to the series. The focus on online interactions, while innovative, can be alienating for those less familiar with internet culture. Additionally, the narrative’s darker themes and graphic depictions of violence may not be suitable for all audiences.
Conclusion
The Ink Black Heart is a bold and ambitious entry in the Cormoran Strike series. It tackles complex, contemporary issues with unflinching honesty, weaving them into a compelling mystery that challenges its characters and readers alike. While the book’s length and divisive themes may not appeal to everyone, fans of the series and those intrigued by its exploration of modern digital life will find much to admire.Ultimately, the novel is a testament to Galbraith’s ability to craft intricate, character-driven stories that resonate on multiple levels. For readers willing to immerse themselves in its sprawling narrative, The Ink Black Heart offers a thought-provoking and rewarding journey into the darker corners of human nature both online and offline.
Affiliate Disclosure: Some of the links on this site may be affiliate links, meaning at no additional cost to you, we may earn a commission if you click through and make a purchase. This helps support Crimes in Bramley and allows us to continue to create content. Thank you for your support!
Richards Osman’s “The Thursday Murder Club” and brand new Crime series “We Solve Murders” reviewed Here.
